top of page

EXPLAINER-Soccer-The case of Lassana Diarra v FIFA

Updated: Nov 22, 2024

Football Soccer - France v Russia - International Friendly - Stade de France stadium, Saint-Denis, France - 29/03/16. French soccer team player Lassana Diarra . Charles Platiau
Football Soccer - France v Russia - International Friendly - Stade de France stadium, Saint-Denis, France - 29/03/16. French soccer team player Lassana Diarra . Charles Platiau

PARIS - Former France player Lassana Diarra's case against soccer's world governing body FIFA will be ruled on by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on Friday.


Here is what it at stake:


1. WHEN WILL THE CJEU DECISION BE ANNOUNCED?


The Diarra v FIFA case features on a list of CJEU decisions, which are usually made public in Luxembourg from 0730-0830 GMT (0930-1030 local time).


2. WHAT IS THE FIFA RULE IN QUESTION?


FIFA’s Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players (RSTP) says a player who terminates a contract before its term "without just cause" is liable to pay compensation to the club, and where the player joins a new club they will be joint and severally liable for payment of compensation.


3. HOW DID IT END UP IN A EUROPEAN COURT?


In 2014, Frenchman Lassana Diarra left Lokomotiv Moscow one year into a four-year deal and the club took the matter to FIFA's Dispute Resolution Chamber (DRC), arguing he had breached the rules when his contract was terminated after the player decided to leave without just cause following a pay cut.


Diarra received an offer to join Belgian club Charleroi, who backed out after FIFA refused to sign the International Transfer Certificate (ITC), preventing the player being registered with the Belgian federation.


In 2015, FIFA ordered Diarra to pay 10 million euros ($11.05 million) in damages to Lokomotiv, prompting the former Chelsea, Arsenal and Real Madrid player to sue the world governing body and Belgian FA before a local court.


Eventually, the Belgian justice system sought guidance from the CJEU, asking if FIFA's rules were in line with articles 45 (freedom of movement of workers) and 101 (prohibition of cartels) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU).


4. WHAT IS THE CJEU RULING ON EXACTLY?


The CJEU will say whether it is unlawful for FIFA to rule that if a player breaches their contract, which is then terminated by the club, their new team is jointly liable with the player to pay compensation to their old one.


CJEU Advocate General Maciej Szpunar has recommended that the judges side with the player.


"Some FIFA rules on transfer of players may prove to be contrary to EU law. These rules are of restrictive nature and may only be justified in specific circumstances," he wrote in a non-binding opinion.


5. WHAT ARE THE CONSEQUENCES IF THE CJEU RULES IN FAVOUR OF DIARRA?


FIFA would need to amend the article that makes the new club liable for compensation if a player's contract with their previous club is terminated. Although the Premier League, the biggest source of transfer funds in the world, is outside the EU it would be affected by any regulation changes as it falls under FIFA's jurisdiction.


Diarra's lawyers said this year that a judgment backing the player would be a milestone in modernising football governance in the bloc as it would allow players' unions and clubs to regulate their employment practices.


"This will put an end to the degrading practice of commoditising players," lawyers Jean-Louis Dupont and Martin Hissel said in a joint statement in April.


($1 = 0.9054 euros)


-Reuters

Comments


Top Stories

Advertise Now (1).png
Tokyo Markets Close Before U.S. Tariffs Take Effect on Wednesday  | US Trade War | Nikkei 225
52:55
White House Briefing: Trump’s AI, Steel, and Coal Strategy | US Politics | Trade War with China
50:14

White House Briefing: Trump’s AI, Steel, and Coal Strategy | US Politics | Trade War with China

WH Press Sec. Karoline Leavitt addresses media after market volatility and Netanyahu's visit. Key updates on Trump’s steel tariffs, AI policy, coal orders, and economic agenda. CEA Chair Steve Miran’s remarks and new White House fact sheets also covered. Stay tuned for insight on trade, tech, and American jobs. 1. ICYMI: President Trump’s Steel Tariffs Mean American Jobs 2. Fact Sheet: Eliminating Barriers for Federal Artificial Intelligence Use and Procurement 3.CEA Chairman Steve Miran Hudson Institute Event Remarks 4.Everyday Americans Support President Trump’s Trade Action 5.White House Releases New Policies on Federal Agency AI Use and Procurement 6.Review of Proposed United States Steel Corporation Acquisition 7.SUNDAY SHOWS: President Trump’s Bold Vision for Economic Prosperity #WhiteHouse #Trump #KarolineLeavitt #AIpolicy #SteelTariffs #CoalPower #USJobs #NetanyahuVisit #EconomicBriefing #HUDSONevent Amaravati Today is a news channel that provides the latest updates on world affairs and sports events. It covers a wide range of topics, including international politics, major global incidents, and sports highlights #WorldNews #GlobalInsights #AmaravatiToday #News #InternationalNews #GlobalNews #Politics Subscribe to the Amaravati Today channel and tap the bell icon to receive notifications whenever we go live https://www.youtube.com/@Amaravati_Today_Official Follow Amaravati Today on x or Twitter: https://x.com/amaravati_today Follow Amaravati Today on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stories/amaravatitodayofficial/ Follow Amaravati Today on Rumble: https://rumble.com/user/Amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/amaravati-today/ Follow Amaravati Today on WhatsApp: https://www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaHWoNe5q08TF4NFKv3d Website: https://www.amaravati.today/ Source: Reuters
Bayern & Inter Post-Match Reactions | UCL QF 1st Leg Press Talks
32:21
Dortmund Press Conference | UCL QF vs Barcelona | Niko Kovac | UEFA Champions League | Soccer
53:11

Dortmund Press Conference | UCL QF vs Barcelona | Niko Kovac | UEFA Champions League | Soccer

Borussia Dortmund head coach Niko Kovac and a key player speak to the media ahead of their UEFA Champions League quarter-final first leg against Barcelona. Get insights into team strategy, match expectations, and more from the pre-match press conference held in Barcelona. Stay tuned for exclusive updates! #Dortmund #Barcelona #UCL #ChampionsLeague #NikoKovac #BVB #Barça #UCL2025 #FootballPressConference #UCLQuarterFinal Amaravati Today is a news channel that provides the latest updates on world affairs and sports events. It covers a wide range of topics, including international politics, major global incidents, and sports highlights #WorldNews #GlobalInsights #AmaravatiToday #News #InternationalNews #GlobalNews #Politics Subscribe to the Amaravati Today channel and tap the bell icon to receive notifications whenever we go live https://www.youtube.com/@Amaravati_Today_Official Follow Amaravati Today on x or Twitter: https://x.com/amaravati_today Follow Amaravati Today on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stories/amaravatitodayofficial/ Follow Amaravati Today on Rumble: https://rumble.com/user/Amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/amaravati-today/ Follow Amaravati Today on WhatsApp: https://www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaHWoNe5q08TF4NFKv3d Website: https://www.amaravati.today/ Source: Reuters
Emery & Aston Villa Speak Ahead of PSG Clash | UCL QF Press Meet | UEFA Champions League | Soccer
44:45

Emery & Aston Villa Speak Ahead of PSG Clash | UCL QF Press Meet | UEFA Champions League | Soccer

Aston Villa manager Unai Emery and a key player speak to the media in Paris ahead of their UEFA Champions League quarter-final first leg vs Paris Saint-Germain. Watch the full press conference as they share thoughts on tactics, team spirit, and the challenge of facing PSG. Stay tuned for more UCL updates from France! #ChampionsLeague #AstonVilla #PSG #UCL #UnaiEmery #UCLQuarterFinal #ParisSG #AVFC #FootballPressConference #SoccerNews Amaravati Today is a news channel that provides the latest updates on world affairs and sports events. It covers a wide range of topics, including international politics, major global incidents, and sports highlights #WorldNews #GlobalInsights #AmaravatiToday #News #InternationalNews #GlobalNews #Politics Subscribe to the Amaravati Today channel and tap the bell icon to receive notifications whenever we go live https://www.youtube.com/@Amaravati_Today_Official Follow Amaravati Today on x or Twitter: https://x.com/amaravati_today Follow Amaravati Today on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stories/amaravatitodayofficial/ Follow Amaravati Today on Rumble: https://rumble.com/user/Amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/amaravati-today/ Follow Amaravati Today on WhatsApp: https://www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaHWoNe5q08TF4NFKv3d Website: https://www.amaravati.today/ Source: Reuters
Prince Harry Appeals UK Police Protection Ruling | Court Hearing | London | Royal Security
05:34:36

Prince Harry Appeals UK Police Protection Ruling | Court Hearing | London | Royal Security

Prince Harry is challenging the UK government's decision to strip him of police protection during visits to Britain. The Court of Appeal in London is hearing his case. This legal battle highlights security concerns for royal family members who step back from official duties. #PrinceHarry #RoyalFamily #UKNews #BritishRoyals #LondonCourt #PoliceProtection #HarryAndMeghan #LegalNews #UKGovernment #RoyalSecurity Amaravati Today is a news channel that provides the latest updates on world affairs and sports events. It covers a wide range of topics, including international politics, major global incidents, and sports highlights #WorldNews #GlobalInsights #AmaravatiToday #News #InternationalNews #GlobalNews #Politics Subscribe to the Amaravati Today channel and tap the bell icon to receive notifications whenever we go live https://www.youtube.com/@Amaravati_Today_Official Follow Amaravati Today on x or Twitter: https://x.com/amaravati_today Follow Amaravati Today on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stories/amaravatitodayofficial/ Follow Amaravati Today on Rumble: https://rumble.com/user/Amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/amaravati-today/ Follow Amaravati Today on WhatsApp: https://www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaHWoNe5q08TF4NFKv3d Website: https://www.amaravati.today/ Source: Reuters
White House Briefing: Trump’s AI, Steel, and Coal Strategy | US Politics | Trade War with China
31:41

White House Briefing: Trump’s AI, Steel, and Coal Strategy | US Politics | Trade War with China

WH Press Sec. Karoline Leavitt addresses media after market volatility and Netanyahu's visit. Key updates on Trump’s steel tariffs, AI policy, coal orders, and economic agenda. CEA Chair Steve Miran’s remarks and new White House fact sheets also covered. Stay tuned for insight on trade, tech, and American jobs. 1. ICYMI: President Trump’s Steel Tariffs Mean American Jobs 2. Fact Sheet: Eliminating Barriers for Federal Artificial Intelligence Use and Procurement 3.CEA Chairman Steve Miran Hudson Institute Event Remarks 4.Everyday Americans Support President Trump’s Trade Action 5.White House Releases New Policies on Federal Agency AI Use and Procurement 6.Review of Proposed United States Steel Corporation Acquisition 7.SUNDAY SHOWS: President Trump’s Bold Vision for Economic Prosperity #WhiteHouse #Trump #KarolineLeavitt #AIpolicy #SteelTariffs #CoalPower #USJobs #NetanyahuVisit #EconomicBriefing #HUDSONevent Amaravati Today is a news channel that provides the latest updates on world affairs and sports events. It covers a wide range of topics, including international politics, major global incidents, and sports highlights #WorldNews #GlobalInsights #AmaravatiToday #News #InternationalNews #GlobalNews #Politics Subscribe to the Amaravati Today channel and tap the bell icon to receive notifications whenever we go live https://www.youtube.com/@Amaravati_Today_Official Follow Amaravati Today on x or Twitter: https://x.com/amaravati_today Follow Amaravati Today on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stories/amaravatitodayofficial/ Follow Amaravati Today on Rumble: https://rumble.com/user/Amaravatitoday Follow Amaravati Today on Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/amaravati-today/ Follow Amaravati Today on WhatsApp: https://www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaHWoNe5q08TF4NFKv3d Website: https://www.amaravati.today/ Source: Reuters
9.png
Live Streams | Facts | Analysis | Explainers | Breaking News

Get in Touch

Manikondu Pvt Ltd
SY. 130P & 115/1P, ISB Rd
Financial District, Gachibowli
Hyderabad, India 500032
letstalk {at} amaravati (dot) today

Follow us on

  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

© 2024 by Amaravati Today | Privacy Policy | Imprint & Dsiclaimer | CIN: U70200TS2024PTC184435

bottom of page